Notes ***UPDATE: We have actually found that it is easier to add the sugar and butter in the pan at the same time (omit the water completely) and let it all melt together until the sugar dissolves and turns a deep caramel color. This way you can actually stir it without ruining it. In fact, it is best if you stir it often so it doesn’t burn. This isn’t the “authentic” way but we have found the end result is the same!